
Jared Stiegelmeyer
Charlottesville Managing Broker
A gated community on a private lake in northwestern Fluvanna County, with a Palmyra mailing address.
A subdivision guide inside Fluvanna County, in the Charlottesville market. Homes for sale are the live feed further down.
Census, the association, and the county tax schedule — quoted, not estimated.
Lake Monticello is a private, gated residential community in northwestern Fluvanna County, and the Census Bureau counts it as its own place. The 2020 census recorded 10,126 residents, up from 9,920 in 2010. The same census counted 27,249 people in Fluvanna County, so the place held a bit more than a third of the county. Mail goes to Palmyra, ZIP 22963. It is not one of the four communities named on the Fluvanna page. Palmyra is the county seat and the postal place. Fork Union, Columbia, and Cunningham sit elsewhere. The housing inside the gates is its own market.
The Lake Monticello Owners' Association publishes its office at 41 Ashlawn Boulevard. The association describes more than 4,000 households around a 352-acre lake. The published geography of the census place is about 8.8 square miles of land and 0.62 square miles of water, with the Albemarle County line on the northwest, the Rivanna River on the northeast, and Virginia Route 53 along the southwest. Membership comes with the residential lot. The owner becomes a member and agrees to the charges. The membership page says the maximum annual dues are set by a vote of the members, and that an improved-property fee covers trash, recycling, and snow plowing of the community's streets. A special assessment needs member approval. Those charges are not the county tax, and the dollar amounts are not printed here.
Fluvanna County publishes a 2026 real estate tax of $0.755 per $100 of assessed value. The Fluvanna Review reported that on April 8, 2026 the Board of Supervisors set the fiscal year 2027 rate at the same $0.755, below an advertised maximum of $0.777. That fiscal year runs from July 1, 2026 through June 30, 2027. A staff packet ahead of the meeting had recommended $0.777. The report is what describes the vote. The treasurer's page is what publishes the 2026 rate.
The Main Gate is on Ashlawn Boulevard, and the association says it is staffed around the clock. Entry without a gate device is through a staffed gate. The access policy treats the device as a privilege for members in good standing, and it says the association may not deny an owner access to the lot. Guests are registered. The same policy names Lake Monticello Volunteer Fire and Rescue. The census place is listed in the Charlottesville metropolitan area. The association places the community about 15 miles southeast of Charlottesville and about 67 miles northwest of Richmond. What is for sale changes every week. The cards further down are the live subdivision feed, filed as Lake Monticello inside Fluvanna County. Every address in that feed uses Palmyra and ZIP 22963. A search for the town of Palmyra mixes in houses outside the gates, including the courthouse village. Ask for the subdivision.
Population is the decennial census, from the Census Bureau's QuickFacts for the place and for Fluvanna County. The lake size is the association's current description. The land and water area are the published geography of the census place. The tax rate is the 2026 figure the county publishes. A local report of the April 8, 2026 budget vote puts the FY2027 rate at the same number, under an advertised maximum of $0.777. The tax is reset with the budget. The tax rate is set annually; check the current year before budgeting.
Route 53 is the road toward Charlottesville. The distances below are the association's, not a drive-time estimate.
Route 53
Virginia Route 53, the Thomas Jefferson Parkway, runs along the southwest side of the census place. The association describes the community as about 15 miles southeast of Charlottesville.
The county line and the river
Northwestern Fluvanna. The published geography puts the Albemarle County line on the northwest and the Rivanna River on the northeast. The courthouse village of Palmyra is a different place, to the southeast.
Richmond
The association says about 67 miles northwest of Richmond. This page does not turn that into a commute time. Traffic on the day decides it.
I-64
The interstate is north of the community. It is not at the gate, and this page does not turn the gap into a drive time.
What the association and the public record actually say. Where something is a trade-off, it says so.
The lake is not a park
The association describes 352 acres.
Swimming, boating, and fishing. Five beaches. The Main Beach is at the end of Ashlawn Boulevard. The association publishes the others at 14 Sassafras Road, 1 Landslide Court, 1 Bench Circle, and 698 Jefferson Drive. The marina, and the boat launch, are at 962 Jefferson Drive. Tufton Pond is a separate 40-acre fishing pond on Tufton Lake Lane. The association says kayaks and other boats without motors are welcome there, and that the pond is not for swimming. None of this water is open to the public.
The gate is the association's
The Main Gate is staffed around the clock.
Membership is automatic with the residential lot. Dues, the improved-property fee, and any special assessment are association charges, separate from the county tax. The membership page says a special assessment needs member approval under the bylaws and the Virginia Property Owners' Association Act. Read the covenants and the current dues before writing an offer. The dollar amount is set by the membership, so it is not printed here.
The course is a club
Eighteen holes. They do not come with the lot.
The club says the course was laid out six decades ago by Buddy Loving, to follow the contours of the Piedmont, and that play is open to the public for a day or for a membership. The association's Fairway Clubhouse is at 51 Bunker Boulevard, with a pro shop and a bistro. A lot makes the buyer a member of the owners' association. It does not include a tee time.
Fluvanna County Public Schools is four schools, one for each grade band the state profile lists. Which building a given street is assigned to is the division's to confirm. The profile says its map may not be an attendance zone.
Central Elementary
3340 Central Plains Road, Palmyra. Pre-kindergarten through second grade. Virginia's fall membership lists 751 students in 2024–2025. The school profile's accreditation heading still reads Accredited for 2024.
Carysbrook Elementary
9172 James Madison Highway, Fork Union. Grades 3 and 4. Fall membership of 457 in 2024–2025. The 2024 profile lists the school Accredited, with none of five quality indicators below standard.
Fluvanna Middle
3717 Central Plains Road, Palmyra. Grades 5 through 7. Fall membership of 747 in 2024–2025. The state profile lists the school Fully Accredited for 2025–2026.
Fluvanna County High
1918 Thomas Jefferson Parkway, Palmyra. Grades 8 through 12, which is why the middle school stops at seventh grade. Fall membership of 1,362 in 2024–2025. The profile lists the school Fully Accredited for 2025–2026.
The beaches, the pond, the parks, and the pool are association property. They are for members and their guests. The golf course is the exception the club itself describes as open to the public.
The lake and five beaches
352 acres, with a marina at 962 Jefferson Drive. The Main Beach is at the end of Ashlawn Boulevard. The other four beaches are the ones the association lists by street.
Tufton Pond
A 40-acre fishing pond on Tufton Lake Lane. The association allows kayaks and other boats without motors, and says the pond is not for swimming.
Three parks
Ashlawn Park is across from the clubhouse at 41 Ashlawn Boulevard, with a playground, basketball, and racquet courts. The association charges an annual fee for those racquet courts. Bunker Park, at 14 Bunker Boulevard, has a playground, a track, and a soccer and softball field. Lafayette Park, at 19 Lafayette Drive, has basketball and racquet courts the association says are open without that charge, and a playground built for children with physical or cognitive limitations.
The pool
The association says the pool was remodeled in 2019 and is open to members and associates from Memorial Day to Labor Day.
Asking prices on the cards are the live feed, and they move. This page does not publish a median, a price per square foot, or a forecast. Budget two separate charges: Fluvanna County's 2026 real estate tax of $0.755 per $100 of assessed value, and the association dues, which the membership sets and which are not quoted here. Golf, if you want it, is a question for the club at 51 Bunker Boulevard.
Live from search.hogangrp.com, refreshed hourly. Filtered to the Lake Monticello subdivision in Fluvanna County.
All Lake Monticello listingsThe subdivision search stays on Lake Monticello. Price and bedroom filters in the form open on Fluvanna County, which is the wider area the MLS files this community under.
Opens search.hogangrp.com in a new tab
The Charlottesville team covers this market, including Fluvanna County.

Charlottesville Managing Broker

Associate Broker

REALTOR®

REALTOR®

REALTOR®

REALTOR®

REALTOR®

REALTOR®

REALTOR®

REALTOR®

REALTOR®

REALTOR®

REALTOR®

REALTOR®

REALTOR®

REALTOR®
Lake Monticello sits inside Fluvanna County. The rest of the Charlottesville market is the same team.
The questions buyers type before they tour Lake Monticello.
Both, in different senses. The Census Bureau counts Lake Monticello as a census-designated place in Fluvanna County: 10,126 residents in 2020. Mail goes to Palmyra, ZIP 22963, and that is the city the MLS prints on the cards. The subdivision name is Lake Monticello. A search for the town of Palmyra is the wider postal area, including the courthouse village outside the gates.
No. The association describes a 352-acre lake with five beaches and a marina, for members and their guests. Tufton Pond is a separate 40-acre fishing pond, and the association says it is not for swimming. The Main Gate on Ashlawn Boulevard is staffed around the clock.
No. The club at 51 Bunker Boulevard says the 18-hole course, a Buddy Loving layout, is open to the public and sells its own memberships. Buying a lot makes the owner a member of the Lake Monticello Owners' Association. It does not include a tee time.
The county publishes a 2026 real estate tax of $0.755 per $100 of assessed value. The Fluvanna Review reported that the Board of Supervisors set the FY2027 rate at the same $0.755 on April 8, 2026, below an advertised maximum of $0.777. Association dues are a second charge. The membership sets the maximum annual dues by vote, and an improved-property fee covers trash, recycling, and snow plowing. This page does not quote the current dollar amount.
Fluvanna County Public Schools. The state profile lists Central Elementary for pre-kindergarten through grade 2, Carysbrook Elementary for grades 3 and 4, Fluvanna Middle for grades 5 through 7, and Fluvanna County High for grades 8 through 12. Confirm a street's assignment with the division. The profile says its map may not be the attendance zone.
Sources · checked November 13, 2026
Census QuickFacts, Lake Monticello CDP · Census QuickFacts, Fluvanna County · Place geography · Owners' association · Lake and marina · Recreation · Membership · Guests and the Main Gate · Access policy · Golf club · 2026 tax rates · FY2027 budget vote, April 8, 2026 · Central Elementary · Carysbrook Elementary · Fluvanna Middle · Fluvanna County High
Mike Hogan founded the brokerage on knowing the county rather than the listing. Ask what that means for this street — or take a cash offer and skip the showings. Neither route commits you to the other.